Sometimes, you just want to have a sweet treat, especially one that you’ve been told has some very real health benefits.
Like dark chocolate.
Typically made with less sugar and fat as milk chocolate, with a higher percentage of fiber, other minerals, and of cocoa solids full of anti-inflammatory antioxidants called flavanols, what could be the harm in that?
Well, according to an article in Consumer Reports published in December 2022 and updated in October 2023, there may be some hidden ingredients in your dark chocolate that can make you very, very sick.
Toxic ingredients like heavy metals: lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd).
Because lead and cadmium are so toxic, this report found that eating a mere ounce of contaminated chocolate every day could put you at risk for harmful levels. Most of us know about lead’s toxicity, but cadmium toxicity is underreported even though it is a major health issue.
To put this in perspective, “Danger in the Dough: Unveiling the Toxic Contaminants in Girl Scout Cookies,” a recent article by pediatrician Dr. Michelle Perro and colleagues, reported that:
100% of the samples were positive for glyphosate (a toxic herbicide)
100% were positive for toxic metals
22 of 25 (88%) of samples were positive for all 5 toxic metals
76% were positive for levels of cadmium that exceed EPA limits in water
24 out of 25 (96%) of samples were positive for lead
Of the 13 types of 25 cookies tested from California, Iowa, and Louisiana, 100% were positive for very elevated levels of glyphosate/AMPA, responsible for multiple health issues including cancer, endocrine disruption, gut issues, miscarriages, sperm damage, autism, neurotoxicity, and reproductive damage. For more information, go to:
No sweet treat is worth that kind of risk.
How Do Lead and Cadmium Get into Chocolate?
Turning the cacao pods into chocolate is a difficult and time-consuming process. Once the pods are opened, the beans found inside need to be fermented on the ground or in boxes for 6-10 days, and then must be dried in the sun, which can take 5-10 days.
Lead can settle on them due to environmental contamination from the dirt, dust, or from old lead pipes carrying water; it can be reduced by protecting the beans, but that’s not always feasible in impoverished communities where resources are scarce.
Cadmium is the other heavy metal in chocolate. It is used in different industries, most notably batteries, plastics, and steel. The pollution and/or wastewater from the manufacturing plants settles in soil and contaminates the growing cacao beans.
How Toxic Is Lead? Very.
You have to wonder how much Queen Elizabeth I suffered, as she painted her face deadly white to cover scars from smallpox with what the Tudors called Venetian Ceruse, a hellish mixture of vinegar and lead. They often left it on for days if not weeks at a time. To compound the toxicity, when she finally did wash her face, it likely was with a cleanser made from rosewater, mercury, honey, and eggshells. A heavy metal double-hitter.
People who work in certain industries are at highest risk for lead exposure. This includes construction and demolition work, paint removal from older buildings, auto repair, and car battery reclaiming and manufacturing. Law enforcement officers who use firearms or work at firing ranges, and those who weld, do ceramics and glazing, or work with glaze or pigments containing Pb are also at higher risk. One of my patients who had a BB gun accident and got a BB in his arm where the fragments couldn’t be removed, tests positive for Pb on a regular basis (even despite treatment, because the BB is difficult to remove).
Due to its toxicity, which is particularly dangerous in young children, there is no level of lead exposure that isn’t harmful. In fact, according to the World Health Organization’s 2021 figures, “nearly half of the 2 million lives lost to known chemicals exposure in 2019 were due to exposure to lead. Lead exposure is estimated to account for 21.7 million years lost to disability and death (disability-adjusted life years, or DALYs) worldwide due to long-term effects on health, including 30% of the global burden of idiopathic intellectual disability, 4.6% of the global burden of cardiovascular disease, and 3% of the global burden of chronic kidney diseases.”
Side effects of lead can unfortunately be silent in most people and chalked up to other causes until chronic symptoms appear, and signs and symptoms depend on the level (amount), frequency, and duration of exposure. Some of the most frequent symptoms of lead toxicity are:
Cognitive difficulties with encephalopathy (memory/concentration problems)
Abdominal pain and cramps
Constipation
Microcytic anemia (smaller red blood cells than normal)
Neuropathy (nerve pain)
High blood pressure
Headaches
Muscle/joint pain
Fatigue and/or insomnia
Irritability
Low libido
Increased susceptibility to infections.
As you can see, many of these symptoms overlap other causes, including diseases like Lyme and associated tick-borne illness, so your doctor may not suspect lead exposure and therefore won’t test you for heavy metal toxicity. Another scary fact is that lead is stored in the bones and can be released in greater amounts when women or men develop osteoporosis. Since some medical complications like hypertension and kidney disease happen later in life, bone loss allows for lead release from storage spaces. In other words, when your bones are in trouble, the low-dose long-term lead exposure you’ve had can result in sudden increases in your blood, increasing toxicity.
One way to estimate how much lead you may have been exposed to is based on symptoms. According to the CDC and ATSDR (Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry), the lowest exposure to Pb may/will cause impaired cognitive abilities, and neurological/psychological/behavioral symptoms, especially in children. Although a patient can and may appear asymptomatic, the first and earliest signs are decreased learning, memory, verbal ability and lowered IQ, impaired speech and hearing, and early signs of hyperactivity or ADHD. Any child with a learning disability, speech and hearing problems, as well as signs or symptoms of hyperactivity, should have Pb levels checked immediately by their pediatrician.
Once the level of Pb rises to moderate exposure, symptoms become much more apparent. Fatigue will increase, as will muscle pain, abdominal symptoms (increased pain, constipation and vomiting), along with increased cognitive difficulties. Tremors and weight loss can also occur at moderate exposure. Finally, high-dose exposure to Pb will lead to even worse abdominal pain (colic, intermittent cramping), decreased levels of consciousness (including coma and death), and even paralysis.
FYI: Mercury toxicity can have any of the above symptoms, which I’ll discuss in next week’s Substack. When checking for Pb toxicity, I usually check for mercury, lead, cadmium, aluminum and arsenic toxicity at the same time.
How Toxic Is Cadmium? Very.
Symptoms of cadmium toxicity can be even more insidious than lead, because Cd affects so many systems in the body. Chronic exposure is a risk factor for cancer (especially breast and prostate cancer) and targets the body’s cardiovascular, pulmonary, gastrointestinal, renal, neurological, and reproductive systems. Acute exposure can cause flu-like symptoms such as fever, chills, weakness, headache, sweating, and muscular pain, similar to getting a viral infection. Chest pain, cough (including coughing up blood) and shortness of breath with wheezing (bronchoconstriction) can also be a problem; if the exposure is high enough, the lungs can fill up with fluid causing acute pulmonary edema (similar to what happens in severe congestive heart failure where the heart is not pumping properly). These symptoms can develop within 24 hours if the level of exposure is high enough, although symptoms of cadmium toxicity usually begin to appear 4 to 10 hours after exposure.
The above symptoms would normally only be seen in those who work as battery or alloy makers, welders, jewelry makers who solder (solder also contains Pb!), miners/smelters, textile workers, or people living near zinc or Pb smelting operations, municipal incinerators, or other industrial processes that emit Cd in the air.
Chronic Cd exposure, on the other hand, is much more frequent. Higher levels of Cd are found in smokers (twice as high as non-smokers), and in those who regularly eat foods and confectionary items (like many brands of dark chocolate, even organic brands) due to contaminated soil. Chronic exposure primarily affects the kidneys, GI tract, and bones, and can cause low back pain and kidney damage/failure along with hypertension (a reason those with poor kidney function due to overlapping causes like chronic hypertension and diabetes should be checked!). It can also increase the risk of osteoporosis, leading to more fragile bones with bone pain from fractures. Since osteoporosis will increase Pb toxicity, releasing it from storage sites in the body, you can see how one heavy metal impacts levels of others.
Symptoms of chronic Cd exposure can include abdominal cramps (similar to what is seen with Pb toxicity), nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea; anyone with unexplained GI symptoms that are unresponsive to standard therapies should be checked for Cd. It can also cause mild anemia (like Pb), and a loss of sense of smell (anosmia). The loss of sense of smell is similar to what can be seen after a COVID infection, while also commonly seen in neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s disease (and can be an early sign that the central nervous system has been affected). Physical signs of exposure to Cd include excess salivation and a yellow discoloration of teeth near the gum line. This is different than Burton’s line from Pb toxicity--a narrow leaden-blue line, about the one-twentieth of an inch in width, while the rest of the gum looks normal.
One particularly insidious long-term effect of Cd is that it’s a risk factor for breast and prostate cancer as well as pancreatic, lung, kidney, and cancer of the nasal cavities and pharynx, while being able to cause changes in DNA that can be passed on to future generations. This is called an epigenetic effect. Since breast and prostate cancer are two of the most common forms of cancer, and nutritional deficiencies increase the risk of cadmium toxicity (people with low calcium, protein, or who are iron-deficient absorb cadmium more efficiently and may be at increased risk), it is important to regularly check for exposure. Age and gender also play a role, as young children with iron deficiency absorb larger amounts than iron-deficient adults, and females absorb more Cd than males (probably in part due to potential iron deficiency from heavy menses).
Next week, you can read all about the toxic effects of mercury, arsenic, aluminum, and asbestos. Hopefully, you haven’t been exposed to too many of them (most of us have low level exposures to heavy metals), but if you have been a frequent consumer of dark chocolate and have any of the risk factors, symptoms or diseases listed above, speak to your healthcare provider about being checked!








